|
Testing Continued
Now it is time to
see if we can push the Pro Series past it's rated speed of 500MHz. After
weeks of testing, we found that it was next to impossible to push the
Pro Series DDR much past 255MHz FSB (510MHz DDR) at any voltage or
memory timings. After countless crashes, I concluded that 510MHz FSB was
all she could do with the Pro Series DDR. Here is what Sandra had to
show at 510MHz:

This is a slight increase
in performance, but very disappointing in the overclocking department.
Conclusion
Corsair's new Pro
Series has to be the fanciest memory I have ever seen. The LEDs are a
very cool feature that really adds to the looks of the interior of a
computer. However, all the lights in the world can't cover up the
problem we had, as well as the problems I've been reading about at other
veteran
hardware sites (sample).
Either the memory wasn't quite ready, or motherboard manufacturers weren't
given the time or opportunity to test the Pro Series with their products
so they could release a bios update. Either way, it looks like Corsair needs to
sit down with P4 motherboard manufacturers (including Albatron, EPoX and
ABIT) and quickly work out these compatibility issues.
Yes, the memory ran
at it's default settings and speed, but only when we increased voltage.
I just shouldn't be necessary to overvolt any memory to achieve default
ratings. Again,
I'm sure a simple BIOS update will cure these compatibility issues, but
for now it's just a waiting game.
As for
overclocking, if you are talking about overclocking a CPU while using
the Pro Series DDR, then it will work just fine for you. However, when
we are talking about overclocking DDR, then the Pro Series failed to do
so with our setup. Again, we are not alone in discovering this.
One extremely important fact I must point out
is Corsair does state
on their website that the Pro Series memory was tested on an ASUS P4C800
motherboard. Unfortunately, they do no state whether or not they tested
the Pro Series with any other brand or model of motherboard. Also, the
only reviews that I have read that favored the Pro Series DDR was tested
on the ASUS P4C800. For now, if you own the ASUS P4C800 or plan to
upgrade to one, you are good to go with the Pro Series DDR.
It does not bring me joy to do this as
Corsair has been a close alley of Club Overclocker for years, but I must
sadly point out flaws when I see them. The world just wasn't ready for
Corsair's Pro Series DDR. I just hope motherboard manufacturers get on
the ball and work with Corsair to iron out these compatibility issues we
found and have been reading about.
|
Club
Overclocker Rating |
|
Innovation: |
9.5
out of 10 |
|
Performance: |
8.5 out of 10 |
|
Quality: |
8.5 out of 10 |
|
Stability: |
5.0 out of 10 |
|
Overclocking: |
5.0 out of 10 |
|
Software Pack: |
N/A |
|
Value: |
5.0 out of 10 |
|
Overall Rating
6.5 |

|