|
Performance
At last, we
finally get to test the 1820A!
Test
System
| Video
Card |
GeForce
FX 5600 |
|
Motherboard |
Iwill
MPX2 |
|
Processor |
Twin
AMD Athlon 1800 MP processors |
| Memory |
OCZ
PC3200 Platinum 2Gb Dual Channel DDR Kit |
| Hard
Drives |
Twin
120gb Seagate SATA V drives |
|
Operating System |
Windows
XP |
For
benchmarking, I'll be using Hard Drive Tach. Here is how things turned out:
Single SATA V drive (non RAID)

Dual SATA V drives (RAID 0)

For
comparison, here are some graphs from our original review on these SATA V hard
drives. Even though the test system isn't the same, this is what you should
expect from an average 32-bit SATA controller.
Single Seagate
Barracuda SATA V
(ABIT NF7-S)

Dual Seagate Barracuda SATA V
(ABIT NF7-S RAID)

Now let's
answer the SCSI question... This test was conducted on the same Iwill MPX2
motherboard, but with an Adaptec 64-bit SCSI interface card.
Twin Seagate
Cheetah 15K.3 SCSI Hard Drives in RAID 0

Conclusion
Single
drive performance is pretty close, but the 1820A in RAID 0 clearly comes out the
winner. Now start adding up all the features the 1820A has...very comparable to
the features you get on today's SCSI interface cards. As for the SCSI
question...drive for drive, SCSI RAID still kicks the crap out of any SATA RAID setup. Of course
there are faster SATA hard drives out there, but they still don't compare to
SCSI speed, reliability, and even manufacturer's warranty. Not yet anyway.
However, if you go all out and run the RocketRAID 1820A with 8 drives, data
speeds go through the roof! With all 8 channels, the transfer speed is up to
1200MB/s for RAID 0 configuration, and 530MB/s for RAID 5. Now if this is true
data transfer rate, then this card is actually superior to SCSI. HighPoint sent
over some benchmarks of their own showing this card at it's best.
Take a look here. As for cost, would you believe that this card will
soon be available for right around $164? The RocketRAID 1820A is an awesome card
and I highly recommend it!
|
Club
Overclocker Rating |
|
Innovation: |
10
out of 10 |
|
Performance: |
10 out of 10 |
|
Quality: |
10 out of 10 |
|
Stability: |
10
out of 10 |
|
Overclocking: |
N/A |
|
Software Pack: |
9.5 out of 10 |
|
Value: |
10
out of 10 |
|
Overall Rating 10 |
|
|
|
|
Skill Level |
|
Project Skill Level
(10 being hardest) |
3
out of 10 |
|