Archives
Contact
Contests
Downloads
Forum
History
Links
Reviews
Home


Antec
Cooler Master
Futuremark Corp
Geeks.com
Gigabyte
Kingwin
Mushkin
OCZ
Patriot Memory
Plextor
Raidmax
Sapphire Tech
Seagate
Sigma

Best viewed with
Internet Explorer v7.0
@ 1024x768 or larger.
Copyright © 1997 - 2007
by Club Overclocker
All rights reserved
Legal Stuff

Application:

IDE Hard Drives

Provided by:

Seagate

Available at:

NewEgg.com

Review by:

Paul

Edited by:

Scott

Review date:

March 22nd, 2004
   
 

Testing

     I searched the internet for some good testing tools and found several.  Unfortunately, HDTach 2.70 is the only one that is a free download.  While we would like to show you every benchmark on the planet, we also want tests that you can duplicate at home without buying benchmark programs.  HDTach also seems to be the most popular hard drive benchmark, so we're all set.

 Test System

Case ThermalTake Lanfire
CPU P4 3.0C 800MHZ FSB HTT
Motherboard Asus P4C800-E Deluxe
RAM 1GB OCZ PC4500
Video Radeon 9800Pro
Storage Seagate 7200.7 200GB Ultra ATA 100 (x2)
Power Fortron-Source 530w power supply
Optical Lite-On 4x DVD+/-RW
Optical Lite-On 52x24x52x CD-RW

I ran the test on the drive as a single drive and as a RAID array.  Let's check out the results.

     Single drive access time 15.3ms, maximum read 66.4MB/s and average 53.5MB/s.  The Read Burst is 82.1MB/s and CPU utilization is 3.3%.

     In a RAID 0 array the performance improves just like it's supposed to.  Access time 15.6ms. maximum read is an outstanding 147.9MB/s and average is 59.9MB/s.  The CPU utilization is just 2.8%.  Now let's talk about the Read Burst Speed.  Obviously, 1428.9MB/s is way off.  We have no answer for this anomaly.  We ran the test several times and it was always about the same.  The only answer that we have is the test is not properly dumping the 2, 8MB cache buffers and is getting readings from that.  Throughout the testing done to these hard drives the temperature was constantly measured.  The temperature of the drives never exceeded 35șC.

Conclusion

     Seagate has done a fantastic job of getting the most out of an Ultra ATA hard drive.  The speeds shown from these drives rival that of a fast SATA hard drive.  The price on these drives are outstanding as well, only $151 for a 200GB hard drive.  The performance on these drives is great.  These are the perfect drives, if you don't have SATA on your current drive.  SATA still has advantages over IDE, but these drives give you a very solid and fast option.

Club Overclocker Rating

Innovation:

9.5 out of 10

Performance:

9.0 out of 10

Quality:

9.5 out of 10

Stability:

10 out of 10

Overclocking:

N/A

Software Pack:

N/A

Value:

9.5 out of 10

Overall Rating 9.5

Project Skill Level
(10 being hardest)

3 out of 10