Archives
Contact Us
Contests
Downloads
Forums
Guides
History
Links
Mailing List
News
Reviews


Antec
Cooler Master
Futuremark Corp
Geeks.com
Gigabyte
Kingwin
Mushkin
OCZ
Patriot Memory
Plextor
Raidmax
Sapphire Tech
Seagate
Sigma

Best viewed with
Internet Explorer v7.0
@ 1024x768 or larger.
Copyright © 1997 - 2007
by Club Overclocker
All rights reserved
Legal Stuff

 

   

Application:

Enterprise Storage

Provided by:

Seagate

Available at:

NewEgg.com

MSRP:

$534.99

Availability:

Now

Review by:

Darren

Edited by:

Scott

Review date:

May 17th, 2006

 

 

 

Test system:

     For this review I will be installing the drives onto an ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe motherboard using the latest nForce 4 Raid controller and providing a true 3Gb/s SATA interface.  I tested the drives both singly and in a RAID 0 (Striped) array. The stripe size is the default 128 Kb set by the controller.

Hardware Model

Operating System:

Windows XP

Motherboard:

ASUS A8N-SLI Deluxe

CPU:

AMD Athlon 64 3000+
Socket 939

Video Card:

ATi X1800XL

Memory:

2gb OCZ Gold GX XTC Edition
PC-4000 DDR
3-4-3-8

Testing:

     For benchmarking the 7200.10 drives I will be using HDTach 3 from SimpliSoftware.  For comparison, I will also be using Sisoft's Sandra 2005 Sr2.  HDTach is a great free utility that allows benchmarking and drive comparisons.  Sandra is an industry leader in performance tuning and benchmarking.  A free Lite version can be found on their website.  For comparison, we will also fire up a Western Digital Raptor 74 GB RAID 0 array and see how well the Seagate drives look.

First I tested a single 7200.10:

     As you can see from the above chart, we are performing just under the rated 78 MB/s transfer rate at 66 MB/s and even getting a pretty solid 9.8 ms random access time.  The Average Write of 43 MB/s is respectable for any performance drive, more so for a 750 GB!  It's also nice to see a burst speed of 135.1 MB/s for those common short reads.

Next I created a RAID 0 array with the nForce 4 Raid Array tool:

     In the short test the performance jump provided by a RAID 0 array is immediately visible.  Our speeds jump across the board with an Average read of 112.5 MB/s and a Random Access Time of 14.3 ms.  The Average Write speed increases to 107.3 MB/s and, lets not forget the often quoted Burst Speed with a huge jump to 192.5 MB/s.  If you don't have RAID 0 array running in your high performance box, this should be all you need to see!

     In the HDTach long test the RAID array does even better on average banking in both a solid 115.7 MB/s Average Read  and a 106.7 MB/s Average Write with very little drop in both Random Access and Burst Speed numbers.

     So we all know that Seagate Barracudas are the king of storage size, but how do they stack up against the industry's speed leaders?  The answer may surprise you!  Using the stored RAID 0 data for my two WD Raptor 74GB drives as a comparison we can see the Seagate 7200.10 bests the Raptors in Sequential Read and Average Read.

     Sure the Raptors can do 8.6 MS Random Access speeds but can your Raptors do this??  That's 1.36 Terabytes in RAID 0.  Who's your Daddy now?


Click on image for larger version

     For a second opinion, I used Sandra to benchmark the Seagate 750's against the top drives on the market for speed all running in RAID, and for good measure I even used Gigabytes hot new virtual I-RAM drive.  The results are again better that you would expect.  The 7200.10 drives finish third following behind the Gigabyte I-RAM RAM drive and slightly behind a set of 36 GB Raptors drives.  Not to shabby for the king of storage size.

Conclusion:

     The Seagate barracuda 7200.10 hard drive is simply the best possible storage drive available today.  Not only has Seagate provided ground breaking storage capacity, they have paired it with solid performance numbers nearly on the level with the WD Raptor drives.  Seagate as proven that you don't have to sacrifice performance to get the storage you need today.  Seagate 7200.10 drives are also some of the quietest drives I have tested as well.  Ten years in the making and I just cant wait to see what Seagate will do next.  Can you imagine these drives with the Cheetah 15K speed or even the throughput of the latest Serial Attached SCSI technology?  Look no further than Seagate to make these parings a reality soon.  With a 5-Year warranty to back it all up, Seagate has become the must have storage leader with the 7200.10 series.

Best Price: $499.99 from Newegg


 

Club Overclocker Rating

Innovation:

9.0 out of 10

Performance:

9.0 out of 10

Quality:

10 out of 10

Stability:

10 out of 10

Overclocking:

N/A

Software/Drivers Pack:

N/A

Value:

9.5 out of 10

Overall Rating 9.5

Skill Level

Project Skill Level
(10 being hardest)

3 out of 10